Ep. 235 Transcript

Disclaimer: This is transcribed using AI. Expect (funny) errors.

Mindy Peterson: [00:00:00] I’m Mindy Peterson, and this is Enhance Life with Music, where we explore all the ways music can make our lives better – health, happiness, and beyond. Have you ever heard a song and suddenly found yourself entirely somewhere else? Maybe you were reliving a memory you hadn’t thought about in years, imagining a future conversation, or drifting into a vivid inner world that you can’t quite explain. Most of us think of those moments as random daydreams or background mental noise. We might even see them as wasted time. Or if it happens during a concert, a failure of attention, getting distracted. But what if those moments are actually revealing something profound about how music shapes our emotions, our memories, creativity, and even our sense of connection to one another? What if they are one of music’s essential functions? Doctor Elizabeth Margulis has spent years studying this fascinating phenomenon. She is a professor of music at Princeton University, where she directs the Music Cognition Lab. Her work bridges music, psychology and neuroscience, and her award winning books include “On Repeat: How Music Plays the Mind.” Doctor Margulis began her career as a conservatory trained pianist before turning to cognitive science to explore why music has such a powerful ability to transport the mind. Her latest book, just released today, is called “Transported: The Everyday Magic of Musical Daydreams.” Congratulations on today’s book release and welcome to Enhance Life with Music, Elizabeth.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:01:48] Thank you so much. It’s so great to be here.

Mindy Peterson: [00:01:50] One concept in your book that really jumped out at me is the idea that music is one of the last spaces, a last refuge where our mind is still free to wander. And I had never thought about it like that. But it’s so true. Talk to us a little bit about why that freedom is so rare today, and why there is value in letting the mind wander.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:02:16] Absolutely. So, you know, I see the moments now where are we used to kind of get lost in our own thoughts, increasingly populated by screens, by social media. I’ve seen household members who shall remain nameless, you know, scrolling while doing the dishes or transferring the laundry. So there’s just vanishingly fewer opportunities for your mind to wander in this way that used to, by best estimates, occupy 30 to 50% of our waking hours. So, you know, one exception potentially is listening to music where there is some kind, right? There’s the the sound is going on. But, uh, you know, if you’re listening over headphones or what have you, it’s sort of decoupled from this super overstimulating, you know, visual aspect and all the other kinds of sensory channels. So it let’s, you know, gives there’s some kind of trigger there in the sound, which ends up being very much what the book, uh, is about. But there’s still this freedom to, uh, for, for your mind to drift. So I, one of the things I’m hoping to do with the book is that when this happens, when you listen to music, that you recognize that this can be a wonderful, um, positive way of interacting with the music rather than some kind of failure of attention.

Mindy Peterson: [00:03:46] Yeah. It can be a catalyst rather than a failure.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:03:49] Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. And in fact, often where it feels like we’ve really kind of gone off somewhere that is. You know, there’s no accounting for that. There is some kind of architecture to what seems like an incredibly personal, subjective, momentary journey. Yeah. And, um, there’s meaning to be plumbed there and interesting things to be found.

Mindy Peterson: [00:04:14] Yeah. Well, in your book, you say music in many ways marks the last refuge of the daydream. And I thought after I read some more about what you were saying about the screens and the stimuli and all of that, that’s just incessant. I thought, oh my gosh, it’s totally true. Like, if I’m standing in line at Costco, normally in years past, that would have been daydream time, or I would have talked to the people around me, you know, and just.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:04:38] Yeah. Exactly. You know, and that.

Mindy Peterson: [00:04:39] Go ahead.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:04:40] Well, I think now just standing in line might be too much in 2026, right. People can’t do it. It’s like they’re going to take out their phone. I’ve seen it happen.

Mindy Peterson: [00:04:49] Totally. I take out my phone. I’m like, any emails come through, you know, since I last checked or I’ll catch up on Instagram or something like that.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:04:57] Exactly. But I see students walking around, they’ve got if they’ve got headphones in, they’re kind of a little more chill, right? They’re not manically taking out their phone. And it has like kind of just enough to carry them somewhere and let their mind kind of, you know, sit on something and go somewhere without that incessant need to stuff something else in front of your. Yeah.

Mindy Peterson: [00:05:21] Well, and also our culture has really become obsessed with productivity. And I am as guilty as anyone. Like I’m sort of a productivity efficiency nerd. I love it. But I think back to my childhood, I experienced boredom. I had plenty of time to just lie on the grass, on the hill, in the back of our yard, or sit on the swing in the swing set and just let my mind wander. And I loved that. And kids today don’t. They’re not really given the opportunity to be bored.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:05:50] Exactly. And that’s part of how you make sense of who you are, right? Because what happens when your mind is wandering is that you’re going through these kind of scenarios, right? You’re remembering things that happened to you. You’re imagining other things that could happen, thinking about the past. You are creating your own story right along along the way. And without the time to do that, it’s hard for the various threads of your life to cohere in the way they really need to, for you to be well in this.

Mindy Peterson: [00:06:20] Oh my gosh, I love how you said that. Making sense of who we are and whatever you said about the threads of our life kind of coming together and cohering. Yes, yes, yes.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:06:30] I wrestle with this all the time as a parent, as you know, somebody who grew up in the 70s and 80s, right? Like I was just, you know, I was left to myself to do and do what I would.

Mindy Peterson: [00:06:41] Totally. Yes. Yeah. After reading your book, I know we’re pretty much the same age, so totally relate there. Yeah. Well, you bring together neuroscience, psychology, ethnography in this book. Explain just a little bit about what is happening in the brain when we become transported in this way by music.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:07:00] Yes. So one of the things we’ve found, and this was really only possible once we had learned that we could play, people knew excerpts of music they’d never heard before, and just ask them to imagine whatever they wanted, and then tell us what story they imagined that we learned that people tend to, you know, even though they’re by themselves and they’re having this very what feels like a very personal imagining, where they go tends to be defined by the music in some really key ways. So certain excerpts tend to take people to a city street in the 1920s. Other excerpts tend to take them to a meadow where a sun is rising and tiny creatures start to frolic like literal words. When you ask people what they imagined for certain excerpts, the word frolic will just emerge in the majority of responses. And to me, that’s just so wild because, you know, people could say anything, right?

Mindy Peterson: [00:08:00] Well, that’s not a word that we use very often. The other thing.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:08:04] It’s fascinating. Yes. So we basically, once we learned that was happening, we could take advantage of that in an MRI scanner because now we could bring people in, play them music that we knew from behavioral studies was liable to make them imagine a certain story, or we could bring them in and play them narration of somebody reciting that story. And so now what we can do is compare the brain activity between the cases where you’re just listening to music and imagining a story. And when you’re listening to just like a literal description of the story. And once we had that kind of ground truth for what’s going on in music listening, we saw all this activity in higher order areas like the default mode, the default mode network that underlies mind wandering in exactly this kind of thought that we’ve been discussing cropping up in these very excerpt specific ways. So, you know, a certain excerpt activates certain specific patterns in the default mode network. And another excerpt triggers another distinct pattern of activity. So we could really see these excerpts, specific kind of patterns that shows us that this kind of mental journey that’s characteristic of, you know, scene construction, mind wandering in other kinds of tasks is also active in music listening.

Mindy Peterson: [00:09:30] You mentioned that default mode network. And that was another thing that really caught my attention in your book. Like I’ve heard that term before, and you did a really good job of explaining it. And one thing that really I came away with is that’s the mode, the network that our brain engages when we don’t have a specific task or response that’s being asked of our mind. And that’s a lot of times when music listening is happening. And it could be when we’re driving, it could be when we’re folding laundry and we don’t need the brain to be actively engaged in something else. Like our hands are carrying out a manual. You mentioned a family member doing dishes, things like that. But.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:10:12] Exactly.

Mindy Peterson: [00:10:13] Anything else you want to say to kind of describe that default mode network and why it’s so important in this conversation about musical daydreams?

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:10:21] Yes. I mean, if you think about music listening, part of the entire point is that it’s non-utilitarian, right? It’s not a job like you’re not, you don’t have a goal. You’re, you’re specifically pursuing. Right. In this kind of overt, task oriented way. So that’s all kind of wrapped into how it works. This is exactly how you can kind of have an aesthetic experience that involves this kind of daydreaming, right? You can only do that when you’re able to let go a little bit.

Mindy Peterson: [00:10:53] And that is that seems to be key is just letting go. It it’s like going into that network, that default mode network. There’s this softening of the focus. It’s just kind of letting go enough that certain things can rise.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:11:07] Emerge.

Mindy Peterson: [00:11:08] And yes, yes.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:11:09] Because that’s the thing that is so interesting to me about music is I think about it as kind of a sticky flypaper. Do you know what I’m talking about? Yeah, yeah. And so basically, you know, kind of whatever’s happening in the world around you, music kind of just grabs on to that and it sticks to it. So, um, a great example of, you know, looking at how this unfolds in the laboratory is a study by Jamal Williams, who was a PhD student here at Princeton. And in his work, he had people come in to the scanner and either watch in its original version, the entirety of the movie The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, or the movie in a version where the soundtrack had been completely wiped. So there’s no music, but there’s still all the dialogue and sound effects. All of that is intact. And by comparing brain activity in clever ways between the version with the soundtrack and without, he was able to show that if you’re watching a scene where a tune plays that had already played in a previous scene, you’re actually reactivating brain activity from the previous scene. So from the content of the previous scene, so, you know, those those melodies have attached to them. The things that happened in the movie when they were initially played. And I view that as just a lovely kind of demonstration across the short time frame of a movie of kind of the way this is working across our entire lifespans. Yeah. Can you come up with some really unexpected resonance that.

Mindy Peterson: [00:12:56] Right. Well, and you mentioned in your book too, how music and those, those melodies have the ability to embed in them, people and places and things and memories and, and so when we hear that melody, it’s so much more than sound that it’s bringing back into our between our ears, our brain.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:13:20] And I mean, we see this from the very earliest age. So I’m thinking of this study where they played babies, one of two very similar melodies. And the melody could be played for them either by a toy where it just played a recording, or it could be sung to them by a stranger over Zoom or in person by a parent, and then they just wait months and months and then Replay. You know, that melody or this other very similar one to the same babies. And only in the case where babies had first heard the melody sung to them in person by a parent, did they especially pay attention to it and, and remember it and be invested in it? Right. So from the very earliest stages, music is, is, you know, fundamentally social and is carrying this kind of contextual information along with it, which is so interesting because so many times we lapse into thinking about music as this kind of abstracted away thing that’s like in its own realm. And so part of this for me is just kind of helping us reconnect with the way that music is actually deeply embedded in all facets of our life and world.

Mindy Peterson: [00:14:34] Sure. And you talk in the book about how music does have this unique superpower in that way to unlock memories and transport us into daydreams more so than smells, than pictures, faces, words. And it kind of because of what we were just discussing, which is so fascinating. As we alluded to earlier, we can tend to equate daydreaming with distraction or a waste of time. Your book completely reframes it. It’s not just meaningful, but an essential function of music. You describe daydreaming as an innate music listening practice that may well constitute one of music’s most essential and neglected functions. And your book is about the ways that music can tip us into a trance state, and the value inherent in that form of letting go, which I love that. But to talk to us about what are some of the essential functions that daydreams can be used for and are being used for?

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:15:36] Yes. So, you know, one thing I think we see a lot already, which is people turning to music for mood regulation, right? Like that’s pretty ubiquitous. And that’s something people, you know, people do pretty intuitively.

Mindy Peterson: [00:15:53] And really hit the news a lot during like the Covid 19 pandemic.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:15:58] Yes, absolutely. And people have seen that, you know, the kind of memories that music elicits tend to be social memories. So, you know, there’s this reminiscence bump for music you listen to a lot during your teenage years. And, um, you know, and.

Mindy Peterson: [00:16:16] For listeners who haven’t heard, there is an episode on the reminiscence bump, so I’ll link to that in the show notes.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:16:21] Amazing. Perfect. Continue on. And so when you’re reactivating these memories, they also tend to be quite social. That’s also a quite a time of your life when you’re, you know, forming your identity or hanging out a lot, right? You’re with, with other people quite a bit. And they often tend to be self-defining. So they, you know, memories that are important to, you know, your sense of who who you are. So all of those can play this kind of important, definitive kind of role. And, you know, if I’m really feeling down, there is something really low barrier to entry about hitting play on a song that’s, you know, easier than other advice you get, like, go take a walk, but then you have to like, get out of bed. Sometimes when you feel really bad, that’s, you know, not the most obvious thing, um, where, you know, just hitting play can kind of sometimes jolt your thought scape out of the rut that it’s stuck in, right? And just shift you into some other kind of internal thought scape that can, you know, really start a positive spiral right into some better frame of mind. So, so I think there’s this very kind of everyday use of music that reflects some intuitive knowledge about this power.

Mindy Peterson: [00:17:43] Oh, there’s so much in there to unpack of what you just said. So, I mean, one, one thing I just want to make sure listeners are catching is the every day impact and the everyday application and use that we can, we can use this to regulate mood. We can use this as, as you mentioned earlier, just getting to know ourselves more and understanding more of who we are just by going into these musical daydreams and having this.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:18:10] Getting curious about them, right? Rather than being like, oh, I didn’t pay attention, you know, or oh, that was my mind was wandering. It’s like, oh, you know, like really introspecting about what the experience is and kind of asking yourselves questions about it that I found that extremely illuminating. Oh, there’s a lot more there than we would first give it credit for.

Mindy Peterson: [00:18:31] Totally. Yeah. It’s like this personal insight that we can gain into our own consciousness or our subconscious. Exactly. As these things kind of emerge and float to the top when we’re in that default mode network. Kind of like these personal insights. Self understanding your book, there’s a quote you said, these daydreams allow us to connect more directly with parts of our thought scape that had seemed impenetrable, which I just love that so much. But then moving even deeper for people who do have diagnosed anxiety, depression, ADHD, PTSD, you mentioned this low barrier to entry and yeah, maybe it’d be great to get out and take a walk. And you mention in the book how therapists really do prescribe that people with these conditions seek out novel, a novel environment, get out of bed, leave the house. All of that can help sort of jump start them out of a downward spiral of thinking. Or if they get kind of stuck in a rut of thinking. But sometimes that barrier to entry is a little too high. Was somebody with depression. And music is just so easy. You can just hit play and kind of get yourself jumpstarted out of that negative thought pattern.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:19:48] Exactly. And people tend to know what is the right song for them, right? It’s not about like, how can I find the magic song that for? Right. There’s, I think there’s also this aspect about trusting yourself and, um.

Mindy Peterson: [00:20:07] Your own intuition.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:20:08] Yeah, exactly.

Mindy Peterson: [00:20:09] Yeah. And sometimes you’re feeling sad and a sad song might be perfect for you, which is kind of a paradox in itself. How sad music can sometimes make us feel better.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:20:20] Yes. I think of that sometimes. That consoling effect that sad music can have around, you know, when you’re having there’s someone who’s a really good listener, really good conversation partner, really. It feels like they can like sit with the thing that you’re trying to express, right, without necessarily trying to solve it or something like that. So there’s something about that kind of way that a sad song can make you feel heard or not alone or something. Oh, totally. That I think, is part of that apparently paradoxical effect.

Mindy Peterson: [00:20:56] Yeah. Well, you refer to this use of music in the book as off label use of music, which I love because we’ve heard that term used before. Off label use of pharmacological, you know, pills. And so I love that description for music. You were talking earlier when I said, there’s so much to unpack here. You were talking about how music, when we listen to it in our youth, a lot of times it’s in social settings and as adults too, but primarily during that adolescent time where that reminiscence bump is, you know, when we’re experiencing that. Mhm. And also music is part of creating our own identity. There’s these self-defining moments that memory really plays into and contributes really meaningfully to who we are and what our story is. And all of those things are hugely important for people using music for people with dementia. And that music memory is the last to fade away. And you mentioned in your book The Alive Inside documentary, which I absolutely love. I’ve talked about that on the show many times, and that it’s almost eerie watching that documentary to see how music from people’s youth does make them come alive when they’re virtually unresponsive and don’t recognize loved ones, and they’re uncommunicative because of their dementia. Yes.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:22:20] Every semester that I teach my undergrad lecture on music cognition, students come up to me and tell me about family members who they’ve seen have really experience it every single year. I would say it’s the most common. Just yeah. Anecdotal thing that a student brings to me about their own witnessing of music’s power in their their own personal life. Wow. Yeah.

Mindy Peterson: [00:22:45] Incredible. Well, and then the other thing I wanted to touch on too, is I’ve had a lot of music therapists as guests on the show, love music therapists. I’m always just blown away by what can be done with music therapy. So I’ve heard about the Barney method of guided imagery and music, but in your book, you went into the history of that. It was developed by.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:23:08] It’s so interesting to me.

Mindy Peterson: [00:23:12] Oh my gosh, I had no idea that’s how that method came to be.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:23:15] And isn’t it amazing? I feel like that. I feel like we need, you know, someone’s looking for a book topic. We really need an excellent book about Helen Bonny.

Mindy Peterson: [00:23:25] Ah, I agree 100%.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:23:27] Fascinating person.

Mindy Peterson: [00:23:28] So just to, I mean, listeners, get Elizabeth’s book and read it for yourself, but just like quick, you know, cliff notes on it. She was sort of tapped to help out at the Maryland Psychiatric Research Center, helping as kind of an aid with patients who were they were being treated with LSD and kind of this psychedelic trip to try to put them in these altered states of consciousness for treating people with PTSD and schizophrenia, depression, all different kinds of situations. A lot of times background music was being used just sort of as an afterthought. Not much thought was being put into it. And Helen Bonny well, actually, why don’t you explain a little? I’ll let you explain. You can explain it better than us. How she kind of used that experience to as a spring. Spring for her Bonny method of guided imagery.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:24:20] Yeah. She just noticed because. And, you know, I loved this kind of like historical sidebar that, you know, there was like some requirement that somebody in the room had to be female when the, the patient was female or something. So that meant because she was a woman, she was in way more of these sessions than she would otherwise have been. So she just got to witness a lot and, um, noticed across the course of, you know, being involved in so many of these that whatever was playing in the music seemed to be materially affecting the content of the journey that the person was going on. And, you know, she was had grown up as a violinist and had this kind of insight that like what, what would happen if we just tried this with the music, right? And just forget it. Forget about the drugs. Yeah. Um, and sort of just tapped into this kind of latent psychedelic potential that’s in the music itself. And that’s more or less what the guided imagery to music program is. Right? Is it’s very much like the way these LSD programs were, but using music.

Mindy Peterson: [00:25:29] And also like not only LSD, but there’s some corollaries to hypnosis, meditation. And yeah, she just recognized that, hey, we can do this and achieve these states of altered consciousness just with musical daydreams, with, like you said, without the drugs.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:25:47] Yeah, yeah.

Mindy Peterson: [00:25:49] And in your book, you said: “In an age of fascination with magic mushrooms, there’s perhaps no ordinary experience that is more psychedelic than the mere act of listening to music.”

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:26:01] Yeah, I really some, you know, I there are so many things about music that are like this to me. An example is earworms, where it felt like people kind of thought that it was weird that they had them and like, didn’t really pay attention to them until, you know, they started doing some research on it and they were like, wait a minute. More than 90% of people are having earworms really frequently. And then that really shifted the discourse. And you can there are actually papers that track on Twitter, for example, mentions of earworms and you can like watch this completely change once it becomes in the public sensibility that an earworm is a thing. And it’s actually a way of understanding how our memory works. And it’s actually interesting. And people start being like, oh, I have this song stuck in my head. It’s this and, and talking about it kind of on the internet. And I guess one of my hopes about daydreams is that the same thing happens, right? This thing that we’ve sort of been, you know, discounting that once we kind of like turn our attention to it and think about it and really notice it, that we’ll appreciate it for how kind of bizarre and fascinating and illuminating it actually is.

Mindy Peterson: [00:27:15] Sure. One other sort of everyday application of musical daydreams that I loved is you were talking about runners and how marathons are fueled by musical daydreams as much as by Gatorade. And it’s kind of like this analgesic effect where runners are using these musical daydreams to sort of take their attention away from their toe blisters and their sore hip flexors and into a more joyful realm. And so it does have this sort of painkiller effect on us. And then the other use of musical daydreams that I just wanted you to touch on to is it as like fuel for creativity? That was really fascinating and totally makes sense. So talk to us a little bit about how essential musical daydreams are for creativity.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:28:08] So in one project, we have looked at standard measures that are used in the field to assess individual differences in like trait level differences in creativity, like to the extent that you can have a measure of, you know, we could argue about whether this is a valid measure, but like the, to the extent that people think there is a measure that can like tap into a person’s creativity. We used those agreed upon measures, and then we had people daydream to music. And then what we did is we looked at the relationships between the content of the daydreams and these trait level measures of creativity. And one of the interesting things we saw was that the people who score higher on standard, like non-musical measures of creativity, were also the people whose just whatever intuitive thing they imagined to music, paradoxically, tended to be more similar to what other people imagined in response to that piece of music. Yes. And so what we think is happening there is that perhaps when you’re kind of more attuned to associational chains, like you’re able to kind of like go from one prompt to the next really kind of rapidly, like take that influence and go with it. Um, that that’s one important piece that allows you ultimately to be really creative. Um, it’s just like a certain openness or alertness, right to things that are incoming. So instead of being kind of like straight ahead with the thing you’re trying to accomplish, that something can come in like, like a song and the song, you know, is connoting something about floating in feathers and you’re immediately able to be like, oh, floating in feathers, right? There’s some kind of mental pivot that that requires that seems to be correlated with trait level creativity.

Mindy Peterson: [00:30:04] Huh.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:30:05] Pretty interesting.

Mindy Peterson: [00:30:06] Yeah. Fascinating. Well, as you were describing that, it just reminded me back to what you were saying earlier in the conversation about the word frolic and that how that comes up so often with people. And I just have to say, like, I would be remiss if I didn’t share this piece of information from your book that blew me away, is that so many people have the same musical daydreams to the same songs, which I found so fascinating. In your book, you talk about how when you get lost in a musical daydream, you. We probably think about. We’re getting lost in our own little private world.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:30:41] Exactly.

Mindy Peterson: [00:30:42] But really, like, if you happen to be in Starbucks and you mentioned a Norah Jones tune, if that’s playing and you kind of get caught up in your own little musical daydream, chances are really high that all the other people around you are having the same musical daydream, which blew me away.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:30:59] I know it’s.

Mindy Peterson: [00:31:00] Especially if we’re like the same age as them, and it makes sense. Like you were talking about how people who are of a similar age, language, educational experience probably have the same songs, kind of crop up at their high school proms or and on the radio and amusement parks or camping trips or grocery stores, things like that. And so you probably are having some of the same memories as the people around you. I just.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:31:26] Exactly. It’s a great way to typify your experience in the Starbucks line is you just contemplate the right. Whatever weird thing is happening in your, you know, head is likely happening in some of your other line mates.

Mindy Peterson: [00:31:40] Yeah. Or even like some of lists, symphonies and some of the classical music that was used in Tom and Jerry cartoons. You know, that was such a great example too. Yes.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:31:49] And the crazy thing is the way how good we are at categorizing new music. So even when it was never used in a Tom and Jerry episode, we can like abstract the elements of music that was used in Tom and Jerry episodes, and then instantly have that association for something we’ve never heard before. And so to me, that is also just an example of how sophisticated we are actually as listeners. So these, these daydreams that seem like, oh, we’re just kind of naive or something are actually reflecting this incredibly deep and complex taxonomy of sound that we’ve just, without even trying. Developed across the course of our lifespan.

Mindy Peterson: [00:32:28] Fascinating. With your research and just the process of writing this book, did it change the way that you personally listen to music or how you use it in your life?

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:32:39] 100%, I would say this is the project that most moved me from where I started because, you know, I had been trained as a pianist at a conservatory where it was really all about, um, uh, you know, musical structures and notes and little technical things. Right. And almost to the exclusion of this kind of more associative realm that I end up talking about in the book. And it was really only through talking closely with students initially that I came to see how important this mode of listening is and how much I was actually neglecting it in my own life. And they really started this, you know, journey, this spark of curiosity for me that led to all this research and to a different way of orienting to music now myself as a listener.

Mindy Peterson: [00:33:32] Oh, interesting. Well, I know we’re running out of time here. The last question that I have for you before the coda is actually maybe too close to the coda. So as, as you. So I’ll, I’ll ask, ask the question. Yeah. So these might sort of blend together. I’m guessing they probably will. I was going to ask if listeners want to experiment with becoming more transported by music this week, what would you encourage them to try? And then the coda, as you know, I ask all my guests to close out our conversation with a musical ending, which I call the coda. By sharing a musical tool that you wish more people knew about, which could be a, a book, a blog, an app, a therapeutic tool, or anything that enables them to enhance their life with music. So do you want to answer those together as a hybrid or separately?

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:34:23] Well, I can sort of give a short answer to the first one and then focus on the second. I think that what I would suggest to people about giving themselves, themselves a chance to be more transported by music this week, um, I would say it’s about, you know, if you’ve ever done those kind of biofeedback, you know, little thing where you have to move a cursor by relaxing paradoxically and not focusing. I don’t know if you’ve ever tried.

Mindy Peterson: [00:34:47] I don’t think I have.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:34:48] It’s really a strange experience. But same thing, right? It’s the job is not having a job. The job is letting go. Music’s playing. You have no jobs. You’re so used to having jobs all day. Now there’s no job. And, um, voila. You know, get your let yourself get curious about what happens.

Mindy Peterson: [00:35:06] Um, well, and as you were describing that, that makes me think about as, I mean, you’re a pianist and so you can relate to this too, or any musical, any musician of any instrument, you practice and practice a song and perfect it to get ready for performance when you actually get to the performance, sometimes the hardest part is just letting go and let yourself do what you’re trained to do. Because we get in front of an audience and our conscious mind just will not relax. And we just overanalyze every single thing that we’re doing and every single note we’re about to play. And we can kind of dig ourselves a hole and shoot ourselves in the foot in that way.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:35:44] Yes. I mean, same thing as a listener, right? You can be cursed by training in that, you know, you’re just listening kind of critically and like, oh, well, I would have used my pinky there. Like whatever, you know? Um, yeah. So this is a little bit like antithetical to that. Um, and then in terms of a tool that I would strongly recommend to listeners, because this has been so valuable in my own life is talking about your musical daydreams. Okay. This may with other people advice with other people. Okay, here’s why this first might seem bad is because if you talk about like, if your friend is like, I had this weird dream last night and they start talking about it. That’s usually so bad and so boring and such a conversation killer. But the thing about musical daydreams is because there’s some shared actual percept in the world, like namely the music itself. When someone describes their kind of internal imaginings while listening to it, it’s this unbelievable opportunity to get behind their ear and into this sort of subjective sense that they’re having of their sensory world. And two things can happen. One is you have strikingly similar imaginings, which we now we know is very often the case.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:36:59] And then that’s this wild kind of point of connection that’s really interesting and fun. And then the other is that it’s something very different. And that’s also really fascinating. So this has been great for me with both my parents and with my teenage children, right? Because there’s with my kids, there’s just no better conversation starter than like, they play me a song they love. And I’m like, this sounds like I don’t. Know to me. And they’re like, well, what I hear and like, right. And then there’s this whole world that they have associated with it that, you know, I knew nothing about and really changes not only how I hear the song. So it’s, you know, helped me become connected into and excited about whole other genres of music that I knew nothing about previously. Um, but it has also just helped me connect to the internal life of my kids. Whereas, you know, when there’s nothing to ground it, it’s really hard to talk about your internal life with another person, especially your child. It’s like, yeah, that feels weird. But if you’re really talking about a song, it’s grounded in this extremely useful way.

Mindy Peterson: [00:38:02] Wow, what a great way to spend the time on a road trip. If you’re with your family in the car for a long period of time, or even just shuttling kids around to their different activities.

Elizabeth Margulis: [00:38:12] 100%, it’s been it carried us all the way from new Jersey to Maine very happily. So I can recommend it.

Mindy Peterson: [00:38:19] Love it.

Transcribed by Sonix.ai